Top Gun: Is it just nostalgia goggles, or does it still soar?

Okay, folks, Priya here back from another deep dive into the cinematic archives. I recently rewatched Top Gun (the OG, naturally) and I'm conflicted. I remember loving it as a kid, the adrenaline, the romance, the sheer coolness of it all. But how does it hold up in today's landscape of global cinema with all its nuances and complexities? On one hand, the aerial sequences are still breathtaking. Even knowing they're dated effects, the dogfights are genuinely thrilling. And Tom Cruise, young and impossibly charismatic, really sells the cocky-but-talented Maverick. But then you have the dialogue, which...oof. Some of it is so cheesy it makes my teeth ache. And the romantic subplot with Charlie? While Kelly McGillis is brilliant, her relationship with Maverick feels a bit forced and underdeveloped, especially compared to some of the more subtle and emotionally resonant romances I've seen in, say, Wong Kar-wai's films. Goose's death still hits hard, though. That scene gets me every time, even knowing it's coming. It's a pivotal moment that gives Maverick some real depth, forcing him to confront his flaws and the responsibility that comes with his skill. So, is Top Gun a flawless film? Absolutely not. Is it a fun, nostalgic ride with iconic moments? Absolutely. It's a bit like a comfort food movie – you know it's not haute cuisine, but sometimes that's exactly what you need. But I have to ask: does anyone else think the volleyball scene is just...weird? I mean, what's the point besides gratuitous shirtless shots? I guess I am not complaining though. Just saying... Ultimately, I think Top Gun is a product of its time, and that's okay. It's a classic for a reason, even if some of its elements haven't aged as gracefully as, say, Jeanne Moreau. I'm curious to hear your thoughts! Am I being too harsh? Or are you also starting to see it with fresh eyes after all these years? Let me know!