53
reviewSpoilers

Star Trek IV: Whale of a Time (and a Change for Nimoy)

Okay, so I'm working my way through Nimoy's directorial efforts, and after the pretty grim "Search for Spock," we get this... complete 180. "The Voyage Home" is just fun. Like, genuinely laugh-out-loud, feel-good fun, which isn't something I usually associate with Trek. And as a director, you can really see Nimoy's confidence growing. The comedic timing is spot-on, the pacing's great, and he manages to balance the sci-fi elements with the Earth-bound stuff remarkably well. I mean, watching Spock try to understand 20th-century slang? Priceless. And the whole scene with Scotty trying to use the 80s computer with voice commands? Genius. It's those little character moments that really shine, and Nimoy gives each actor something great to work with. Even Chekov's accent feels less...offensive? Maybe I'm just used to it, haha. What I find most impressive is how Nimoy managed to make a movie about saving the Earth from a giant space probe actually be about environmentalism and, like, respecting other species. It's not preachy, though. It's just woven into the narrative really well. I was worried the whole whale thing would be kinda silly, but it actually ended up being really touching. Overall, I'd say this is a solid directorial effort from Nimoy. Definitely a departure from the heavier themes of earlier Trek films, but a welcome one. It's a great example of how to balance humor and heart without sacrificing the core values of the franchise. It's not perfect, but it's definently among the better Trek installments, and a very rewatchable one at that. He really knocked it out of the park, and it's got me even more excited to see what else he directed beyond Trek.

jordancinephile
2 months ago
4 comments
116 views
Sign in to join the discussion

Comments (4)

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!